Skip to main content
main content, press tab to continue
Article

Supporting new professionals: Confronting the culture of “eating their young” in healthcare

By Joan M. Porcaro | August 13, 2025

Bullying in healthcare can harm new professionals. Discover ways to build a respectful, safe environment and strategies to prevent workplace bullying.
N/A
N/A

Bullying behavior is widely condemned in work settings, yet it continues to surface in environments where it has no place, particularly for those who are new to their roles or their industry — whether holding paid or volunteer positions. In truth, bullying is incompatible with any healthy work culture, no matter what the industry setting or the timing.

The phrase “eating their young” is a metaphor often used in healthcare to describe the phenomenon where experienced staff mistreat, intimidate, or undermine newer or less experienced colleagues or committee members. While it's vivid, it's also a serious reflection of a toxic workplace culture that can damage morale, retention and patient care.

Defining workplace bullying

In general, bullying in the workplace can take several harmful forms, including verbal abuse, threatening or intimidating behavior and deliberate interference with a person's ability to perform their job. These actions may be overt or subtle, but they all contribute to a toxic environment that undermines employee well-being and organizational effectiveness.

According to the Workplace Bullying Institute, bullying involves actions that are threatening, intimidating, humiliating, or interfering with a person’s ability to perform their job.

Prevalence and impact

According to the 2024 WBI U.S. Workplace Bullying Survey:

  • 32.3% of adult Americans report being directly bullied at work — about 52.2 million workers
  • 74.8 million have either experienced or witnessed bullying
  • 51% of bullied targets are women; 30% of women and 34% of men report being bullied
  • Most common bullying dynamic: male perpetrator targeting male victim (36%)
  • African Americans report the highest rate of bullying (57% affected)
  • 75% of bullies act alone, and 55% are in supervisory roles
  • 62% of targets lose their jobs due to bullying — via termination, transfer, or resignation

Impact on individuals and organizations

Bullying leads to:

  • Emotional distress and mental health issues: Workplace bullying is strongly associated with anxiety, depression, PTSD and other psychological disorders. A study cited by Forbes notes that 60–63% of bullying victims exhibit PTSD symptoms, and 75% show signs of psychiatric distress.
  • Decreased productivity and morale: According to the Palgrave Handbook of Workplace Well-Being, bullying contributes to absenteeism, reduced productivity and loss of motivation, ultimately harming organizational performance.
  • Erosion of trust in leadership: When bullying is ignored or tolerated, especially when perpetrators are in leadership roles, it undermines employee trust in management and organizational integrity.
  • Increased turnover and reputational damage: Research published in BMC Public Health links workplace bullying to higher turnover intentions, particularly when employees feel unsupported or unsafe.

Who becomes a bully?

In the article, A Relational Framework for Understanding Bullying, the authors state, “bullying is aggression that operates within relationships of power and abuse.” The article highlights the relational and social dynamics that distinguish bullying from other forms of aggression. Bullying involves intentional harm, whether physical, verbal, or psychological. It’s not accidental or playful; it’s a deliberate act meant to hurt, intimidate, or control. The term “abuse” emphasizes that bullying is not just about conflict or disagreement, it’s a misuse of power. The aggressor exploits the imbalance to repeatedly harm or degrade the victim, often with lasting emotional or psychological effects.

Traits commonly associated with workplace bullies

  • Emotional instability: Easily angered, irritable, or reactive under stress
  • Low empathy: A lack of concern for others’ feelings or well-being
  • Need for control or dominance: Desire to assert power over others, especially in hierarchical or competitive environments
  • Insecurity or fear of being outperformed: May feel threatened by competent or newer employees
  • Disregard for rules or norms: Unconcerned with organizational policies or respectful conduct
  • Professional jealousy where there's concern that the new colleague is getting “too much” attention

Bullies can be found at all levels of an organization, including:

  • Leadership
  • Seasoned coworker
  • Peer groups
  • Informal leaders targeting coworkers
  • Any relationship with a power imbalance

Who becomes the target of the bully?

According to Laurie Scop at the National Workplace Bullying Coalition (NWBC), targets of workplace bullying “are highly skilled workers…with integrity and are very ethical people inside and outside of the workplace…you’re singled out because you are different in some way, even if the way that you’re different is positive.”

Characteristics that attract the attention of the bully include:

  • Being intelligent, determined, creative
  • Regularly contributing new and innovative ideas
  • Going the extra mile and gaining recognition for your hard work
  • Moving through projects quickly while others are struggling
  • Being a perfectionist and striving for success

Eating their young

Bullying from seasoned coworkers toward newer employees is a well-documented and harmful dynamic in many workplaces, including healthcare. This behavior often stems from power imbalances, resistance to change, or insecurity, and can severely impact the onboarding experience, morale and retention of new staff.

Common examples of workplace bullying

  • A seasoned employee misdirects a new colleague to embarrass them publicly
  • A director sabotages a staff member’s work through deceit and manipulation
  • A competent staff member is undermined by a bully or bullying group seeking control
  • An informal leader mocks a colleague, eroding their credibility
  • A staff member reports bullying but faces resistance or retaliation from the leadership
  • A colleague who was victim of bullying within the organization

Key characteristics of bullying by seasoned employees toward the less experienced colleague

  • Gatekeeping: Withholding information or resources that new employees need to succeed, refusing to help when asked
  • Gaslighting: The target of the bully is blamed for the problematic issues or toxic relationship
  • Sabotage: Intentionally setting up new staff to fail or publicly correcting them to undermine confidence
  • Exclusion: Leaving new employees out of team communications, meetings, or social interactions
  • Mocking or belittling: Making jokes at the expense of new staff or questioning their competence
  • Undermining authority: Disregarding the input of new leaders or professionals, especially if they are younger or from underrepresented groups

Why it happens

  • Fear of change: Long-term employees or group members may feel threatened by new ideas or approaches
  • Insecurity: Some may feel their status is at risk and act out to maintain control
  • Lack of accountability: If leadership tolerates or overlooks bullying, it can become normalized

Impact on new employees

  • Increased stress, anxiety and burnout
  • Lower job satisfaction and engagement
  • Higher turnover rates
  • Hesitation to speak up or contribute ideas

Strategies for new employees facing workplace bullying

New employees who encounter bullying should take proactive steps to protect their well-being and professional development. Begin by documenting incidents and patterns of behavior, including dates, times and specific actions. This record can be essential if formal reporting becomes necessary. Seek support from human resources, trusted mentors, or an Employee Assistance Program (EAP), if available.

Additionally, consider engaging a certified professional coach who can help you navigate workplace dynamics, build resilience and develop strategies for managing difficult interactions. Building positive alliances with team members who model professionalism and respect can also provide a sense of safety and support.

Finally, make sure to familiarize yourself with your organization’s policies on workplace conduct and reporting procedures, so you understand your rights and available resources.

Strategies for employers to prevent and address workplace bullying

Employers play a critical role in shaping a respectful and psychologically safe work environment. Proactive strategies can help prevent bullying behaviors and support a culture of accountability and inclusion.

Developing a mentoring culture is a powerful way to establish a consistent, value-driven approach to supporting new employees, new managers and anyone new in their role. This helps seasoned employees stay mindful of their influence and encourages them to model behaviors that promote psychological safety and professional development. When embraced across an organization, mentoring contributes to a culture where new employees or committee members feel welcomed, valued and supported.

Set and share clear rules for respectful behavior during the employee's first few days at work and throughout their career. Reinforce these expectations through policies, training and leadership modeling.

Provide targeted training to help supervisors and managers recognize early signs of bullying, understand power dynamics and intervene effectively. Emphasize their responsibility in fostering a safe and inclusive workplace.

Create safe channels for new and existing employees to share concerns. Use anonymous surveys, regular check-ins and exit interviews to identify patterns of toxic behavior and areas for improvement.

Ensure that all staff — regardless of tenure, title, or informal influence — are held to the same behavioral standards. Address violations promptly and consistently to reinforce a culture of fairness.

Foster an environment where employees feel safe to speak up, ask questions and report concerns without fear of retaliation. Psychological safety is essential for team performance and employee well-being.

Offer access to Employee Assistance Programs (EAPs), professional coaching and peer support networks. These resources can help employees navigate difficult situations and build resilience.

Leaders should consistently demonstrate the behaviors they expect from others. Modeling empathy, transparency and accountability sets the tone for the entire organization.

Regularly assess the workplace climate through data collection, feedback and incident tracking. Use this information to refine policies, improve training and address systemic issues.

Additional references and resources

Disclaimer

WTW hopes you found the general information provided here informative and helpful. The information contained herein is not intended to constitute legal or other professional advice and should not be relied upon in lieu of consultation with your own legal advisors. In the event you would like more information regarding your insurance coverage, please do not hesitate to reach out to us. In North America, WTW offers insurance products through licensed entities, including Willis Towers Watson Northeast, Inc. (in the United States) and Willis Canada Inc. (in Canada).

Author


Senior Vice President, Risk Services - Healthcare

Related content tags, list of links Article Healthcare
Contact us