In this episode, Conor sits down with two industry experts to examine two of the most critical issues facing carbon capture and storage (CCS) projects today: insuring the long-term containment of stored CO₂ and verifying storage integrity over time. As CCS deployment accelerates globally, demonstrating that captured carbon remains securely stored for decades is fundamental to project viability, regulatory compliance and stakeholder confidence. These challenges present complex technical, operational and risk management considerations for developers, operators, investors and insurers alike.
As part of a broader series exploring key issues shaping the CCS landscape, this discussion focuses on the evolving approaches organizations are taking to manage long-term storage risks and provide assurance that stored CO₂ remains safely contained. The panel examines the role of monitoring, measurement and verification technologies, emerging industry practices, and the risk transfer solutions being developed to support long-term storage obligations. They also discuss how advancements in monitoring capabilities can help build confidence among regulators, insurers and project stakeholders while supporting the continued growth of the CCS market.
The conversation covers topics including long-term CO₂ containment risks, storage integrity and permanence, monitoring, measurement and verification (MMV) technologies, risk transfer and insurance solutions, regulatory and stakeholder expectations, and emerging strategies for demonstrating secure carbon storage, offering practical insights for CCS developers, operators, investors and industry stakeholders.
Transcript for this episode
RODNEY GARRAD: The future of MMV, it won't belong to those who collect the most data. It'll belong to those who identify meaningful changes in risk and the conditions earliest.
SPEAKER 1: Welcome to the Risk Circuit, a WTW podcast delivering the latest insights into risk trends and challenges across the natural resources industry. With perspectives from leading voices across all key natural resources sectors, you can make decisions with confidence and clarity.
SPEAKER 2: Hello, and welcome to the latest episode of The Risk Circuit podcast. I'm Conor Bayes from WTW, and over the last few years, I've had the opportunity to work with clients, insurers, and industry specialists on a range of CCS-related initiatives, including the development of our CCS insurance solution.
Over the coming weeks, we'll be in a deep dive into some of the key issues facing CSS developers and operators around the world. In today's session, we'll explore two of the most critical issues facing CSS projects, ensuring the long-term containment of stored CO2 and the technologies and monitoring strategies used to verify storage integration over time.
I'm delighted to be joined by two highly experienced guests who bring perspectives from academia, industry, and insurance. First, we have Professor Jon Gluyas. Jon is a geoscientist with more than 45 years of experience across industry and academia. A recognized expert in geoenergy, his work has covered geothermal energy, natural hydrogen and helium exploration, and carbon storage.
He has held a number of senior leadership positions at Durham University, served as president of the Geological Society and chair of the British Geological Survey, and has founded 15 companies, including Geoptic Limited, a King's award-winning business.
JON GLUYAS: Hi.
SPEAKER 2: And last but certainly not least, we have Dr. Rodney Garrod. Rodney is a geologist and energy risk specialist with more than 25 years of international experience, spanning oil and gas, radioactive waste disposal, and energy insurance. He now focuses on risk evaluation for emerging energy technologies, including CCS, bringing a unique perspective that bridges science, engineering and insurance.
Rodney is also a regular writer and speaker on energy and risk, and is the author of the forthcoming book Rock Hard Truths, Energy, Risk, and the Limits of Narrative, as well as the forthcoming first break article, which is very relevant for today's webinar, titled "early warning beats perfect hindsight, why CCS needs a new approach to risk management," which explores monitor ability, conformance, and the role of MMV in building confidence in large scale carbon storage projects.
RODNEY GARRAD: Yeah, hi. Thanks for the invitation to participate. Thank you.
SPEAKER 2: Welcome to you both. It's great to have you with us today. And to kick us off, if it's OK, I'd like to come to you first, Rodney. And for those less familiar with the topic, what do we mean by measurement, monitoring, and verification, or MMV, and why is it such a critical component of CCS projects?
RODNEY GARRAD: Yeah, no, thanks, Conor. Yeah, I guess, at its simplest, MMV stands for measurement, monitoring, and verification, as you outlined. It's simply the process used to demonstrate that you injected CO2, is behaving as expected, remains within the intended storage complex, and it can be independently verified over time.
Traditionally, it's been framed as a regulatory requirement, but I think when you're talking with an insurance cap on here, I think it's more useful to look at it as a risk management framework. The geological model will tell us what we think will happen. MMV tells us what is actually happening. And I think that's an important point.
For operators, MMV demonstrates storage performance, for regulators, it provides assurance, and for investors in insurance, critically, it builds confidence that the project is behaving consistently with the desired expectations. One of the points that I've exploring recently in the paper that you mentioned, it's not really about collecting data as such, additional data. It's more about supporting decisions.
So the value of MMV doesn't really come from the volume of information produced. It really comes from identifying meaningful departures from expectations early enough to act. Ultimately, MMV converts that uncertainty into evidence, and evidence into confidence and confidence is really what the industry needs right now.
SPEAKER 2: Perfect. Thank you very much. Jon, I'd like to come to you next, if that's OK. One of the topics that often generates discussion, both within the industry and amongst external stakeholders, is geo-leakeage. The success of CCS ultimately depends on confidence that CO2 will remain permanently stored over the long term, so understanding and managing any potential migration pathways is critical. How do you define geo-leakage in practical terms, and how is geo-leakage assessed and quantified in practice?
JON GLUYAS: OK, thanks, Conor. Just to really segue between what Rodney said and the question you've asked, one of the other positive aspects, of course, of MMV is that it informs the next project, so long as we're able to share information and best practice. And so some of the things I'll talk about now really depend upon having that portfolio of information.
When it comes to geo-leakage, we can think of two broad mechanisms. One is a pervasive failure of the cap rock, in which case the CO2 or whatever you're storing basically leaks through the cap rock in a capillary fashion. And the second mechanism is whereby the stored gas leaks along a, either pre-defined or created fault line, a fracture. One would be a mass flow through a small aperture crack, the other would be a-- it's like a seepage of-- just think of a wound or something like that over a over a cut and a plaster, then the seepage through that to the surface.
So those are the two broad categories. And, of course, we've got-- oh, we're getting on almost for 200 years worth of knowledge on petroleum systems. And in terms of that kind of leakage, both natural and human-induced have been characterized over the decades, particularly over the last 50 years or so. And so there is a great body of evidence in terms of what to look for when it comes to leakage.
Having said that, the key aspect about geo-leakage or prevention of geo-leakage, in many ways, is a thorough appraisal of where you're going to store CO2 in the first place, and that involves using the sorts of technologies and measurements that are commonplace within the oil industry.
There are some new ones as well to look at the configuration of the proposed storage site, the depth, the rock types which exist there, and make an assessment as to what the potential is for failure of that. And speaking in insurance terms, you'll often find that storage sites are selected not only with a single sealed unit, but with a stack of sealed units such that if the first one fails, then there is an opportunity for secondary seals to stop that movement.
SPEAKER 2: Excellent. Thank you very much. If we take this one step further, how do operators distinguish between natural geological processes and indicators that might suggest unintended migration of CO2?
JON GLUYAS: Do you want to tackle this, Rodney? Let me have a first go, as it were. So as you'll hear, no doubt, from Rodney, the MMV process is not a one off. You are continuously or episodically looking at information which will tell you about the pressure, the migration, the influence of buoyancy and so on of the CO2 in the subsurface. In other words, you're looking for changes through time.
And the changes through time could be in line with expectation. I mean, as we've seen, for example, in the Sleipner storage site in the North Sea, there was the expectation that the CO2 would both move up, dip, and move laterally in a northerly direction. And that's been observed from the repeat seismic surveys, but you're also looking for discontinuities. Is there a sudden drop in the pressure in injectivity, in which case a new pathway of CO2 movement may have been opened up? It's this time series which becomes of critical importance when doing the MMV.
SPEAKER 2: Perfect. Thank you very much. I think we'll come to you next, Rodney, if that's OK. A common criticism being of CCS is that there's still areas of uncertainty surrounding long-term storage performance. While the industry has made significant progress, it's fair to say that there are still some unknowns that cannot be eliminated. Where do you see the biggest sources of uncertainty that remain difficult to measure or quantify?
RODNEY GARRAD: Yeah, great question. I grouped them into four buckets. First of all, there's just your geo geological heterogeneity. Obviously, Jon and I have been in subsurface world for a long time, and we're constantly surprised. And we're surprised for a reason. So even with excellent data coverage, characterization, as Jon was alluding to well, control, the subsurface really is as simple as we'd like it to be. So that's your first general uncertainty.
Then the second, when we're talking specifically about carbon capture and storage, it's that in many of these projects, we're repurposing mature hydrocarbon basins, and there's uncertainty around the older wells, in particular, that they often extend beyond the available records that we have in order to do due diligence and to de-risk them.
The third one, a little bit more complex, is like Jon alluded to it over a time series, but it's the pressure evolution over long periods of time. This is not just a five-year monitoring play. This is multi-generational in some cases. So it's longer than a traditional de-risking of an oil and gas project, conventional project. So that's becoming increasingly important.
And then the fourth is how these uncertainties interact. So individually, we might know a lot about faults. We might know a lot about wells. We might know a lot about plume movement and pressure behavior really well. But the challenge really is understanding how those factors behave together over decades.
And so coming, again, back to that paper that I asked, one question in the paper is, I've become increasingly interested here is, what does the first million tons of injection tell us about our confidence in the safety of storing 10 million tons? So the value of monitoring, bringing it back to what this podcast is about, it's not simply confirming success, it's about identifying the earliest signals that our assumptions may need updating. I think that's of a nice way to frame it.
SPEAKER 2: Thank you very much. Jon, would you like to add to that?
JON GLUYAS: Yes, if I may. I know you've covered old well leakage in a previous podcast, but I think it's worth emphasizing that that, really, is one of the key uncertainties. We did a piece of work some time ago-- in fact, two pieces of work, one for the onshore Environment Agency in the UK and another looking at all the old offshore wells. And in terms of record keeping, there was a broad and, say, quantitative correlation between oil price and the quality of information in the abandonment documents.
And so knowing what's happened to those old wells and how they've been plugged, how they've been capped, is a really big uncertainty. And it's not well-recorded, even to the extent that when we did the piece of work on the onshore, which was for generally repurposing wells, not for CO2, we informed the agency that there are several wells which had been built into housing estates and no one seemed to know. So this record keeping of past generations, it can be quite poor. It can often be very poor indeed.
I think the other thing which Rodney said, which I can pick up on, is this, does the information from the first million tons inform you very well about the first 10 million tons that you're going to store? And, of course, it does in part, but there's so much more to learn.
And I think we often, maybe, forget, with the CCS industry-- I'll illustrate this by a conversation I had with someone from the government agency, maybe, about 10 or more years ago, when I was asked, what research do we need to do before we start injecting CO2, to which my response was, we need to start injecting CO2, and that will inform us as to what kind of research is required.
There are some things we're worried about now that will just evaporate and not be an issue, and many things we've never thought about. And this comes back to another point Rodney made about heterogeneity, which will completely bite you on the backside and really cause horrendous issues.
So we learn by doing, and for sure, the petroleum industry, if we look to that analogy, has improved its performance dramatically from the days when in order to control a well, you throw a bale of burning hay into the wellbore to see where the gas was escaping to current practice, where we have BOPs blowout preventers, which 99 point something percent of the time will save you from disaster.
So we need to do this to be able to know how to improve So insurance will work alongside that. And as we've seen in all other walks of life, the insurance premiums and the design of the products will change through time as we get better. One hopes at least it should do.
RODNEY GARRAD: Yeah, and just to reiterate, what you're seeing at the moment is most of the successful CCS projects that are actually getting up to speed now are the ones that are incrementally scaling. Yeah, precisely because of that point.
JON GLUYAS: Yeah,
SPEAKER 2: Yeah, definitely. Thank you very much. The next question is for both of you. Maybe we'll come to you first, Rodney. Turning to technology more broadly, CSS has benefited from significant advances in monitoring capability over recent years. Many of the tools available today simply weren't available or weren't as a sophisticated a decade ago. How has MMV technology evolved over the past decade, and where are we today in terms of capability and confidence, and is there a single technology that has transformed confidence levels within the industry?
RODNEY GARRAD: Yeah, no. Yeah, I think the industry has made enormous progress over the last decade. Obviously, we have better seismic imaging. We have fiber optic sensing, pressure monitoring, satellite observations, increasingly sophisticated reservoir models.
So for all intents and purposes, the first couple of CCS projects were, relating to today's technology, were almost injecting blind, if we look at relative technology. But from my perspective, the biggest challenge probably isn't, rather, a single technology. It's the way that we think about monitoring.
So historically, monitoring MMV was often viewed, as I mentioned, like a compliance exercise. But I think we need to look a little bit in the insurance direction. Think of it as a risk management tool. So the real question now is not can we monitor, and we can monitor as well. We have lots of experience about this. But can we identify meaningful changes from the model and then, obviously, act accordingly.
So I think what you've seen over time is of a progression from periodic verification towards something like a continuous assurance, and that's what that technology provides. So the stakeholders, insurance, finance, they want evidence that the storage system is behaving as expected. Everybody does. And it builds confidence. And that's built when things are observed to be behaving as they were predicted and aligning over time.
So no, I don't think there's a single silver bullet technology. But what builds confidence is the convergence of all these different observations aligning over time, this time series data. As geoscientists, we really make important decisions using just one data set, right? We don't rely on one technology. We're making observations using different independent data to come to the same conclusion, tell us the same story.
And from an insurance perspective, you don't gain confidence by using one sensor in an apartment block or a warehouse. You have independent lines of evidence, consistent support the same conclusion. So it comes again, it comes back to my most recent paper that the future of MMV, it won't belong to those who collect the most data. It will belong to those who identify meaningful changes in risk and the conditions earliest.
JON GLUYAS: Rodney, I love that phrase. I'm going to remember it and use it, if I may.
RODNEY GARRAD: Yeah.
JON GLUYAS: Thank you.
RODNEY GARRAD: And just another thing is the insurance industry, it doesn't get enough kudos for what it's done for fire mitigation. We didn't improve our safety around warehouses and in the apartment sector here or housing sector by creating better reports after fires. These are the outcomes with fire alarms, detective intervention systems that identified abnormal conditions early enough to act. So I think that's where CCS monitoring, is increasingly moving in that direction.
JON GLUYAS: Can I add a couple of things, if I may? One is a piece of technology, which is an unabashed promotion of something I've been working on. But the other is, when I first arrived in academia from industry, one of the things that struck me about CO2, of course, it's rather like the trash service, and you pay for the trash collection because you don't want next door neighbor's waste on your front garden.
With CO2, of course, that problem is distributed around the globe. And so what we find is that when it comes to, at least, this is nearly 20 years ago, talking about monitoring, there was a tendency to try and minimize the amount of monitoring required because there's a cost to it. And CO2 is a waste product. And I suggested to the energy minister at the time, in the UK, that if you could commoditize CO2, then you make certain you knew where it was going, how it was behaving, and exactly what it was doing in the subsurface.
And to that extent, I initially started to try and promote CO2 for enhanced oil recovery. It's been used in Hungary since the 1950s, and the US since the 1970s, and a handful of countries elsewhere around the world. Unfortunately, in the US, most of the CO2 which is injected is not anthropogenic, but from natural CO2 accumulations.
And the response was a glib one and completely wrong. And that was, you can't have something which is both a waste product and a commodity. And I remembered as a child that my grandmother, on a, I think it was a Wednesday, would wait for the rag-and-bone man, and her waste was his commodity.
So I think thinking about how you commoditize CO2 in a positive way is one of the possibilities for ensuring that monitoring becomes far more comprehensive. And one of the things I'm looking at there is the use of CO2 as a power fluid for geothermal energy, where CO2 remains in the subsurface, it stays in the dense phase and is circulated around to extract heat from the subsurface. So that's one aspect.
But the other one, which I think Rodney nicely highlighted, is this episodic nature of the way in which, at least for the offshore storage of CO2, is highly reliant upon seismic imaging. And seismic survey, you've got to mobilize and subsequently demobilize. You go out into an area and take the survey over a period of time. And then you look at the response between that survey and the one you did a year previously. You're not there continuously, although there are some technologies which can add an extra time dimension.
So there are 364 days when you don't what's going on. And then there is the process time between acquisition and interpretation. And that in itself creates this episodic measurement. But, of course, with seismic surveys, you've also got a intrinsic noise, the different weather or sea conditions, which is irreducible. And that will add uncertainty into your measurements.
So when I started working on, now 14 or 15 years ago, was the opportunity to use cosmic ray muons, which are extremely penetrative, to look at density changes in the subsurface. And so we have-- this is the company that you mentioned at the beginning, the award-winning company, does now have a tested tool for continuous monitoring of CO2 24/7.
It doesn't have the spatial coverage that seismic has because you need to have instruments in the subsurface, but it doesn't require a created signal. And there are others. We're not the only ones who've developed this. There's a similar system being developed at one of the, I think the Lawrence Livermore Lab in the US, but we're seeing an emergence of technology dedicated to CCS.
We've talked exclusively, really, about the transition of or transfer of technology from petroleum into CSS. But there's also the transfer of technology from geothermal. Geothermal energy has a much smaller revenue base than petroleum and uses a different array of technologies, which are typically lower cost, one being microseismicity, to record the movement of, in that instance, cold water or hot water in the subsurface that's now being applied to think about CO2 and how that migrates in the subsurface.
So we're seeing a gathering of technologies from different industries to supplement that which, in a sense, the CO2 industry is inheriting from petroleum.
RODNEY GARRAD: Just to bring it back to something that, maybe, your audience can understand a little bit better is if, for example, you have a plan of your house and you want to know where the fires are happening in your house. So if you've done your geological de-risking, you know that there's going to be a leakage from-- not every room in the house is potential leakage pathway, but some are worse than others. So you're going to put your sensors in the rooms that makes the most sense to try and catch that leakage as early as possible.
And that's where I'm getting at with this continuous assurance piece rather than this periodic evaluation, where I don't need a complete picture of my house once a year. I need a continuous picture of this house, in particular, some high-risk zones like the kitchen, where you're probably going to expect a fire now and then, right? That's what I was implying.
JON GLUYAS: Exactly. Yeah, completely at one with you there, Rodney.
RODNEY GARRAD: Yeah.
SPEAKER 2: Thank you both very much. That's really interesting. And I think that leads us nicely onto the next question. Perhaps we can start with you, Jon. As monitoring technologies continue to evolve, how do you see regulators balancing the adoption of innovative tools against the need for confidence and consistency in containment verification?
JON GLUYAS: I think that's a really tough question, actually, Conor. My experience to date has been, and this is largely limited to the UK, is that the regulators are typically playing catch up with the evolution of MMV technology. Understandably so as well. And so the sorts of criteria that are being written into the plans or the processes for CO2 storage are written in a way to encompass new technology as it emerges, but without being prescriptive on a particular type of technology.
I'm not sure that you can necessarily do too much better than that from a regulatory point of view. A lot of the regulation, of course, is around quantity of CO2 retained for a period of time, which flips back into how good is your MMV. I think I'm going to try and hand that over to the Rodney, who's probably got a far more comprehensive answer for you.
RODNEY GARRAD: I think Jon, towards the end of his answer, was getting on something there, where we've probably talked about containment, conformance, and storage in terms of our geological characterization to try and prove concept, right? And we do that for a reason because if you can't prove you've got a safe store, then your business case collapses effectively.
And I think what has been forgotten a little bit is about the monitoring side of things. So I would suspect, from a regulatory point of view, and I agree with you on that, generally one or two steps behind the industry in terms of understanding their technology.
Now, they need to get up to speed, and the containment side of things, they've probably got a good handle on. That's probably nothing new, the conformance. But things like pressure management and effective risk management, especially around continuous assurance monitoring, that's probably where they need to get up to speed with.
SPEAKER 2: Excellent. Thank you. The next question is, how does a strong MMV program translate into greater confidence for project developers, investors, insurers, and regulators, and which aspects most directly influence risk assessment? Perhaps I can come to you, Rodney, for that one.
RODNEY GARRAD: Yeah, I alluded to it at the start of the podcast. It creates confidence in the industry. It creates a track record. Currently, the industry doesn't have both. So that's where I would start really. I don't know if you want to elaborate on that, Jon.
JON GLUYAS: No, I think that's all too clear. We have, maybe, a little over-- 1996, I think, was when Sleipner came as the first injection process. So we've got 20 years of monitoring of one program and rather less than that on a handful more. This will take some time. I think Rodney's covered the key points there.
SPEAKER 2: Excellent. So we're on to our final question, and I'll come to both of you for this one. I'd like to look ahead and ask, with CCS deployment accelerating globally, and we're seeing different regulatory approaches come into existence, geological settings and project designs varying across the jurisdiction, as CCS scales globally, do you expect MMV approaches to become more standardized or will they remain highly site-specific? What would you think best practice will look like? Who would like to take that one first?
JON GLUYAS: I'll try. There is always going to be a degree of site specificity because, again, going back to one of Rodney's very early comments, the subsurface is heterogeneous and it's heterogeneous at a scale that we understand but can't necessarily describe adequately. And so there will be specifics for each project.
There will also be a suite of commonalities between projects. I mean, for example, onshore projects will be monitored typically in a different way from offshore projects. Offshore have been dominated by repeat seismic surveys. Onshore projects, typically early on, we're looking at monitoring for gas seepage from things like soils.
Although with the advent of the In Salah project in Algeria, and the fracturing of the cap rock there, and the impact that had on the surface of the desert in Algeria, folk are now starting to deploy satellite data, which will give far more continuous type monitoring. So there are some intrinsic differences between locations, And best practice will emerge, just as it has in 100 other industries, and particular in the petroleum industry, for things like blowout prevention and risk management there.
Will it homogenize? To an extent, yes. There will be certainly aspects of monitoring and verification which get proven through time and others which get eclipsed. But I suspect each project just in the same way. If you think about development of an oil field, you may drill the first well and find a short oil column.
You then have an appraisal program, particularly if it's offshore, before you have the major investment of purchasing a platform or putting a template on the seabed. You have an appraisal program which is there, is designed to understand the architecture of the reservoir, the way in which fluids will or will not flow from that reservoir. And it will be the same in CSS. You'll have an appraisal program-- the aim of which is to reduce your uncertainty.
They're not always entirely successful. So we get surprises both ways. Storage sites will turn out to be smaller than anticipated, more difficult to inject in some instances, and others much, much bigger and capable of taking much more CO2 benignly. And that will go through time. So it comes back, again, to what Rodney said about the first million and the first 10 million and so on.
RODNEY GARRAD: Yeah, I think the objectives will become increasingly standardized, but the implementation will just become site-specific, as Jon outlined. I think every reservoir is different. You got different geology, different pressure regimes, different whale populations within them, and different monitoring challenges.
But I think in order to come back to the point, they'll need to prove containment. Otherwise, the business case collapses. They'll need to prove conformance, pressure management, and then effective risk management. And those last two are very key in the monitoring side of things. So I expect standardization, probably, around those outcomes rather than around any specific technologies that people deploy.
SPEAKER 2: Excellent. Thank you very much. Jon, Rodney, thank you both for joining. I think one of my biggest takeaways from today's discussion is that CSS isn't simply about injecting CO2 underground. Long-term success depends on our ability to understand, monitor, and ultimately demonstrate that storage is performing as intended.
We've discussed the challenges of containment, the role of MMV in reducing uncertainty, and the existing technologies that are helping to improve confidence across the industry. As CSS scales globally, these topics will only become more important. Thank you for both sharing your expertise and experience with us, and thank you to our listeners for joining. We hope you found today's conversation both informative and thought-provoking. And be sure to join us for the next episode in our CCS podcast series.
SPEAKER 1: Thank you for listening. We hope you found this episode insightful. For more information, visit the Insights section of wtwco.com This podcast is for general discussion and/or information only, is not entirely to be relied upon, amd action based on or in connection with anything contained here should not be taken without first obtaining specific advice from a suitably qualified professional. Thank you.
Podcast host
Speakers
Professor Jon Gluyas
Executive Director Durham Energy Institute, Durham University
Rodney Garrard
Geo Energy Advisor, Arch Insurance International